Three nights were enough to feel far away.
A Thursday-to-Sunday birthday getaway with my girlfriend Nicole became one of my favorite hotel redemptions, a new favorite beach and a reminder that a big trip can fit into a small travel window.
We traveled from Puerto Rico through Miami to Grand Cayman from November 5–8, 2026. The goal was simple. Stay somewhere beautiful, have one unforgettable boat day, eat well and leave enough time to actually enjoy the place. The trip was part of Nicole's birthday gift.
I redeemed 42,000 miles plus $241.42 in taxes and fees for the Miami–Grand Cayman return flights, operated by American Airlines. Three nights at Kimpton Seafire used 210,000 IHG One Rewards points, plus $285 in resort fees. Our recorded cash spending came to $1,186.45 for both of us across the listed expenses.
Seafire became much more than somewhere to sleep, especially after a complimentary corner-suite upgrade. Still, the moment I would repeat first is standing in waist-deep water at Stingray City with rays all around us. This guide follows the actual weekend, with the stays, transport and spending behind it.
One arrival afternoon, two full days and one final morning. The boat trip was our only major scheduled excursion, which left room to enjoy the resort and explore by car.

The credited destination photos throughout this guide illustrate the island. They will be replaced with my own trip photos.
Four days of sailing, stingrays and slowing down.
Arriving in Grand Cayman and an upgrade we did not see coming
The first adventure was staying on the left
We landed at Owen Roberts International Airport around 2:30 p.m., cleared immigration and headed to Hertz. Before we had seen a single beach, I was already having an adventure. Grand Cayman drives on the left, and our rental had the steering wheel on the right. Turning, roundabouts and staying centered in the lane suddenly required actual concentration.
For the first fifteen or twenty minutes, my brain kept repeating, stay left. Then it started feeling surprisingly normal. The car gave us the freedom to leave the resort for meals and explore beaches on our own schedule. Our rental cost $187.59, and we used about $25 in gas over the trip.
Seafire made an impression before we reached the room
At Kimpton Seafire Resort + Spa, the valet team opened the doors and took our luggage. Parking was covered by the resort fee during our stay. Inside, welcome drinks and little pieces of chocolate or fudge appeared before we had even finished checking in. We had been there about five minutes and already felt taken care of.
I have IHG Diamond Elite status, and the trip was part of my girlfriend Nicole's birthday gift, so I asked if there might be an upgrade available. I expected a higher floor or a slightly nicer view. The front desk employee stepped away, came back and gave us an ocean-view corner suite. While it was being prepared, another employee showed us the pool, beach, restaurants, spa and fitness center.
Then we opened the door
We walked into a full kitchen, dining area, living room, separate bedroom and two bathrooms. The corner layout gave us a wraparound balcony overlooking Seven Mile Beach. The main bathroom had two vanities, a big shower and a freestanding tub. Even the bedroom looked straight toward the ocean. We stopped walking for a moment just to take it all in.
Nicole actually got emotional. Seeing her reaction was my favorite part of arriving. Later, my saved trip note put that upgraded accommodation at roughly $2,970 per night on our dates. That was the suite we happened to receive, with a rate I checked during the trip. I would treat a future upgrade as a welcome surprise, since elite upgrades depend on availability.
A workout, birthday strawberries and our first sunset
After getting that ridiculous suite, our first decision was to go work out. We had missed training in Miami, so we did about 45 minutes in the fitness center. Back upstairs, chocolate-covered strawberries and a personalized birthday postcard were waiting for Nicole. Every time we thought the hotel had finished surprising us, it did something else.
We kept the arrival day light and went down to Seven Mile Beach for sunset. White sand, transparent water and layers of blue all the way to the horizon. A few hours earlier we had been on a plane. Now we were barefoot on the beach outside a hotel booked with points. That's when rewards start feeling like actual experiences.
Dinner took us to Cracked Conch in West Bay. I had jerk chicken with rice, beans and sweet plantains; Nicole ordered ribs in a sweet Caribbean-style sauce with potatoes. Spicy, sweet and exactly the kind of meal I wanted after traveling. We finished with a couple of drinks at the hotel bar and finally settled into vacation mode.

Pilates, our own sailboat and a very good beach day
A Caribbean morning with a surprisingly tough Pilates class
Friday started at 8:30 a.m. with Pilates on one of the resort's outdoor green spaces. Warm air, palm trees and the ocean nearby made a good setting for a class that was harder than I expected. Breakfast afterward felt well earned.
At check-in I had selected breakfast as my Diamond Elite welcome amenity, which covered both of us for all three mornings. The buffet would have been about $61.50 per person per day during our stay, around $369 for two over three mornings. The food was good, and having breakfast taken care of made the mornings easy.
Taking a Hobie Cat out from the beach
After breakfast, we changed and walked onto the beach. Non-motorized watersports were included through the resort fee during our stay, so we took a Hobie Cat out for about an hour. We sailed in front of Seven Mile Beach, watched the hotel get smaller behind us and I got to teach Nicole a little about sailing.
Normally I would think of sailing as a separate excursion to arrange. Here, it was something we could do right outside the hotel. That was one of the biggest reasons Seafire became part of the trip itself. We actually used what was included.

Snorkeling, ping-pong and doing very little
When we returned, we swapped the sailboat for snorkel gear and walked into the water. We saw fish and coral right off the beach. Then we moved to the pool for swimming, drinks and a very serious ping-pong match. I won. I feel that belongs in the official record.
Later, we grabbed pastries from the hotel bakery and watched another sunset from the beach. We had no list of attractions to race through. Sometimes we sailed, sometimes we snorkeled, and sometimes we simply sat by the water. That slower pace was exactly what this weekend needed.

Paradise Pizza and one more stop for ice cream
That night we drove to Paradise Pizza for brick-oven pizza. My review was a straightforward 10/10, and I'd absolutely go back. Then we stopped at Scoops Cayman for Devon House ice cream before returning to Seafire. Pizza, ice cream and a quiet drive back. An extremely successful vacation day.
Stingray City, conch ceviche and the beach that surprised me
Coral reef first, then an unexpected turtle
Saturday was our big excursion day. After breakfast, a shuttle collected us from the hotel lobby and took us to the marina. We headed into the North Sound with the captain and another crew member for reef snorkeling, Stingray City and Starfish Point.
At the reef there were fish everywhere, and two stingrays swam near us before we even reached the sandbar. Back aboard, the captain had three conchs and hinted that he had a plan for them. On the way to the next stop, a little sea turtle appeared beside the boat. You can arrange an itinerary, but you cannot schedule that kind of surprise.

Waist-deep water in the middle of the North Sound
Then the boat stopped at Stingray City Sandbar. You're out in the sound, look down and realize the water is only around waist deep. We stepped in and suddenly there were dozens of southern stingrays gliding between people, brushing past our legs and coming straight toward us. They looked much bigger beside us than they had from the boat.
We spent about 40 minutes in the water and got to gently touch them under the crew's direction. At first I was hyperaware of every movement; a few minutes later I was watching how gracefully they moved. This was easily my favorite activity of the trip. The beach and hotel were beautiful, and this was the experience I would make room for again immediately.
Fishermen cleaning their catch in these sheltered waters helped create the gathering that became Stingray City. For a visit today, follow the Department of Environment's guidance. Watching without touching is the preferred approach, keep rays in the water, and let guides handle feeding during group tours.
Cayman Department of Environment — marine visitor guidance

Starfish Point and ceviche made on the boat
At Starfish Point, the shallow water was clear enough to see orange starfish sitting on the bottom. We got in to observe them up close. Leave them underwater and enjoy the view. While we swam, the captain finally revealed his plan for the conch.
He prepared conch ceviche with lime, peppers, onion and seasonings, then served it with chips right there on the boat. It was the freshest ceviche I had ever eaten. Reef fish, a surprise turtle, stingrays, starfish and ceviche on the water made this feel like a complete day in its own right.
Smith Barcadere became my favorite beach of the trip
After the shuttle brought us back, we took the car south to Smith Barcadere, also called Smith Cove. Seven Mile Beach had set the bar very high. Somehow this smaller cove became my favorite. Clear turquoise water, limestone on either side and fewer people than we had seen around the resort beaches made it feel like a little world of its own.
We stayed for hours swimming, floating and doing very little. On the way back we stopped at ICOA, where Nicole tried a fresh chocolate-chip cookie and declared it the best she'd ever had. A new favorite beach and a new cookie benchmark in one afternoon. Very productive research.

Our last night was room service and a movie
Back at Seafire, we had pool time, another drink and one last sunset. We kept dinner easy with room service and used a $25 hotel credit toward eligible charges. Then we sat in the living room of the suite and watched a movie. For the last evening of a birthday getaway, that was exactly right.
One more breakfast, one more swim and home
A final morning on Seven Mile Beach
Sunday arrived too quickly. We had our last breakfast, changed into swimsuits and went back to Seven Mile Beach. No big activity to fit in, just a final swim and a little more time in that water. Eventually we showered, packed, took one last look around the suite and headed to the airport for our afternoon departure.
Three nights had given us a beautiful hotel, sailing, snorkeling, a wildlife excursion, meals we loved and time to relax. I went home thinking about how many other places could fit into a Thursday-to-Sunday trip around a full-time job.
Kimpton Seafire was part of the experience.
We stayed all three nights at Kimpton Seafire Resort + Spa on Seven Mile Beach. Using one base kept the weekend simple, with the beach, pool, fitness center and watersports close enough that we could move between them without planning a whole outing.
210,000 IHG points for three nights
My redemption averaged 70,000 points per night, plus the $95 nightly resort fee we paid during our stay. Award availability and pricing vary by date, so check the full booking details before transferring or spending points.
An ocean-view corner suite and thoughtful birthday details
We received the suite as a complimentary upgrade after asking at check-in. The kitchen, two bathrooms and wraparound balcony were wonderful, and Nicole loved the welcome strawberries and birthday message. The original room is what I would plan around when booking again.
Breakfast, watersports and time at the resort
During our stay, the resort fee covered parking and non-motorized watersports, and we used the Hobie Cat, snorkel gear, Pilates and gym. Breakfast for two came from my Diamond Elite welcome-amenity choice. Check the current activity schedule and your own membership benefits.
A rental car was worth it for this weekend.
Our route was Puerto Rico → Miami → Grand Cayman, then the reverse on the way home. I recorded $64 for the Puerto Rico–Miami leg and another $64 for the return, in addition to the miles and taxes for Miami–Grand Cayman. Those are our trip figures, and airfare will depend on your dates and award availability.
Hertz gave us freedom to go to Cracked Conch, Paradise Pizza, Scoops, Smith Barcadere and ICOA. The car cost $187.59 and gas about $25. We also used the boat tour's hotel shuttle, so that morning required very little coordination.
Our recorded spending for two people.
The cash entries below add up to $1,186.45. The airline miles and hotel points sit alongside that amount. These are the expenses I saved after our November 2026 trip, with approximate gas spending.
| Expense | Our cost |
|---|---|
| Puerto Rico → Miami flights | $64 |
| Miami ↔ Grand Cayman flights | 42,000 miles + $241.42 |
| Miami → Puerto Rico flights | $64 |
| Hertz rental car | $187.59 |
| Gas, approximately | $25 |
| Kimpton Seafire · three nights | 210,000 IHG points + $285 resort fees |
| Recorded food spending | $319.44 |
| Total recorded cash spending | $1,186.45 |
| Rewards redeemed | 210,000 IHG points + 42,000 airline miles |
The boat excursion has no separate price in my saved breakdown. Confirm that cost in addition to the listed expenses when planning your own trip. The $25 hotel credit and breakfast estimate are context for the stay, and are not additional expense rows.
Was Seafire worth the points? I would do it again.
The hotel became part of what we came to do. We sailed, snorkeled, worked out, took Pilates, ate breakfast and watched sunsets without needing to leave the property for every experience. The upgrade made it extraordinary, and the birthday touches made it personal.
My saved comparison showed roughly $746 total for the Miami–Grand Cayman return flights for both of us, and about $2,970 per night for the upgraded suite on our dates. Those were rates I observed, and the suite came through a complimentary upgrade. They explain why the stay felt exceptional, while a new booking needs its own price comparison.
The moments I would repeat first.
- Stingray City. Forty minutes in the shallows with southern stingrays was the defining activity of our weekend.
- Smith Barcadere. I went expecting another beach and left with a new favorite from the trip. Give it an unhurried afternoon.
- Sailing the Hobie Cat. Being able to step outside the hotel and sail with Nicole was one of the best parts of staying at Seafire.
- Paradise Pizza, Scoops and ICOA. Pizza for me, ice cream for both of us and a cookie Nicole still has a very strong opinion about.
- Nicole seeing the suite. For a birthday gift, that reaction was the part I could never have booked in advance.

For three nights, I would keep this balance.
I would keep one arrival afternoon, one resort day, one big boat excursion and a final beach morning. We had enough adventure to make memories and enough open time to enjoy where we were staying. I would not add a second major excursion to this exact weekend.
With five or six nights, I would look into more of the island, including Crystal Caves, Rum Point or a bioluminescent bay outing. Those would be possibilities for a future trip. This one was about enjoying a birthday getaway together.
What I would tell a friend before booking.
Read the currency on the menu.
Grand Cayman was expensive, especially for food. Check whether prices are in Cayman Islands dollars or U.S. dollars, and review service charges before ordering. The official peg is CI$1 = US$1.20, while the rate used by a merchant or card transaction can differ. A CI$20 menu item is more than US$20.
Check what your award stay includes.
Our points booking still had a resort fee. Breakfast came from my Diamond Elite welcome amenity, and the suite upgrade depended on availability. Read the current room, fee and benefits details, and choose the welcome amenity that makes sense for your stay.
Let the crew guide the wildlife visit.
Choose an operator who follows local wildlife guidance and check the route, transfers and weather policy. Observe rays and starfish gently, keep them underwater and leave ray feeding to guides on group tours. Watching the wildlife was the whole reason for being there.
Leave an afternoon for a different beach.
Seven Mile Beach made a wonderful base, but Smith Barcadere was my favorite surprise. Keep a little freedom to explore beyond your hotel and choose swimming plans around the conditions on the day.
Planning resources checked November 17, 2026. The itinerary, prices, elite status and benefits used above describe our November 5–8 stay.
A whole new set of memories between Thursday and Sunday.
I remember Nicole opening the suite door, us sailing a little Hobie Cat, the very competitive ping-pong game and the first moment I realized I could stand up in the water at Stingray City. Then ceviche on the boat, an afternoon at Smith Barcadere and a quiet final night watching a movie.
Grand Cayman gave us a luxury stay made possible with rewards and the kind of weekend that changes how you think about short trips. Three nights were enough for a birthday gift we will remember for a long time. I came home wanting to find the next Thursday-to-Sunday escape.


